Please either log in below,
or create an account.

The Ability to Use Natural Resources Responsibly

Trotta: Lee's catch

Trotta: Lee's catch ~Enlarge

The ability to use Great Lakes water responsible is critical to all of us in the Basin.  Multiple stakeholders invested major time and effort in the development of the Great Lakes-St. Lawrence River Basin Water Resources Compact.  It was passed in the summer of 2008 by the Congress and signed by the President.  The ability of the Region to produce this is very impressive.  Developing and agreeing on the Compact is a noteworthy achievement and a significant example of Regional cooperation.

Retaining the States’ authority to manage water use is a critical element, particularly when it comes to managing diversion and implementing conservation measures. The fact that the States and Provinces are putting into effect provisions to manage the control and use of water, while including protection to prohibit diversions to outside the Basin, is the sort of assurance necessary for industry. Industry is able to understand what it needs to do in order to be able to continue to use the resource.

Industry needs that assured access to water because of many processes that are dependent upon the availability of that water.  Industry is concerned that as States implement the provisions of the Compact, the processes that are put into effect are efficient and non-burdensome, and are supportive of resource use and sustainable development. 

The critical understanding is that water is an eminently reusable resource.  If we handle it properly, it can be used and reused a number of times.

I believe we are very fortunate that the Great Lakes Compact does not lock-up the resource and prevent its use, but rather understands the nature of the resource and its reusability.

Is it also important to realize that use does not mean degradation of the resource.  In multiple cases, the water returned after industrial use to the Basin of of higher quality than what was removed from the Basin to begin with.  We are fortunate to have abundant fresh water - very fortunate.  I believe that over the last three decades we have demonstrated increasing responsibility in oversight and management of the resource, and we have done so as a result of multi-stakeholder input.

 

 

» About author George Kuper

Comments

The Incentive to Use Natural Resources Responsibly

Ability is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for the responsible use of the waters of the Great Lakes Basin.  Water, like other natural resources, is underpriced, due in part to federal bailouts going back at least to the Clean Water Act of 1972.  I believe that proper pricing of water would do much to give users an incentive to find and cultivate that latent ability to use water responsibly, whether inside or outside the Basin.

Retaining the States' authority to manage water is problematic, given they are the recipients of federal bailouts.  The price  paid for bailouts is dependency on the bailers.  Beggars cannot be choosers.

Likewise, industry and other users can be assured that avoidance of paying the full rental value of water up-front can only mean paying in other ways, such as in bureaucratic processes that are burdensome and inefficient.

Water is certainly reusable in nature where it flows in a closed loop.  I am sure industry could mimic nature in this.  And if it is true that in multiple cases, the water returned to the Basin was of higher quality than it was when taken from the Basin, the reused water could be drank in the front office as well as reused in industrial processes. I will drink to that, if you don't  mind that I bring my own bottle.

 

 

 

 

George Kuper's picture

Reply to The Incentive to Use Natural Resources Responsibly

Thank you for your comments.

Access to good drinking water is a human right

I blogged about responsible water use today at http://diggitt.blogspot.com/2009/07/access-to-water-is-human-right-but.html

This was prompted by reading that the Unitarian Universalist Service Committee is supporting moves in California to have water access be an acknowledged human right.  I'm all in favor of that.  But as I have said before on this site, when I think of the greed of developers in the southwest, I tremble for the integrity of the Great Lakes.